• Taleen Krug

What are the Most Affordable Places to Live on Long Island




If you’re thinking about moving to Long Island, you’ve made a good choice as there are many options in this exciting area. Long Island offers affordability, safety, and much more for recently married couples or families with kids.


Perhaps you’re feeling it’s time to venture out and away from the city and start anew in a place where there’s trees, good schools, things to do and so much more.

While some of the neighborhoods in Long Island can be on the expensive side, others are affordable, so don’t fret.


In other words, there might be something for everyone who wants to live in Long Island.

Home prices in Long Island vary from one suburb to another and yes, there are some moderate home prices for those who are interested in buying.

Here’s a brief look at what are the most affordable places to live on Long Island to consider.


1. Stony Brook

The Stony Brook suburb is in Suffolk County in the town of Brookhaven. Its Three Village Central School District is ranked nine out of 10. It has easy access to the Long Island Railroad Station for mass transit riders. The Avalon Park and Preserve are in the neighborhood for recreational and entertainment activities for residents. It is about 56 miles from New York City. The median home value in Stony Brook is said to be $469,200. This is considered an excellent place to raise a family thanks to the highly rated schools and affordable housing. The community is also big into beautiful decoration displays during the holiday season.


2. Smithtown

The town of Smithtown in Suffolk County has all sorts of amenities like easy access to the Long Island Railroad Station if you need mass transit. The public schools are rated nine out of 10 making Smithtown a good option for families with kids or those planning to have children.

There’s also Blydenburg County Park and Caleb Smith State Park in the area for outdoor activities and entertainment. It is located a little more than 50 miles from New York City. The median home value in Smithtown is said to be around $479,100.


3. Massapequa Park

Massapequa Park is a lovely suburb in Nassau County in the town of Oyster Bay. It has some of the best schools in the region. The Massapequa School District is rated with a nine out of 10 on the GreatSchools scale and is a fine choice for raising a family. Brady Park, Colleran Park, and Mansfield Park are in the area and great for outdoor recreational activities and entertainment. The mass transit provider in the area is close and is the Long Island Railroad Station. This neighborhood is a little more than 40 miles from New York City. The median home value in Massapequa Park is said to be around $147,300.


4. Commack

The Commack neighborhood is also located in Suffolk County and the town of Smithtown. The Commack School District is rated with a ranking of nine out of 10. Here you will find Hoyt Farm Town Park and Whitman Hollow Park. The nearest Long Island Railroad Station is in Northport about three miles away. Commack is 43 miles from New York City. The median home value in Commack is reported to be around $473,000.


5. Holtsville

Holtsville is in the town of Islip, Suffolk County. The Sachem Central School District has a rating of eight out of 10. The Wildlife and Ecology Center offers outdoor entertainment and recreational activities in addition to wildlife education. The Long Island Railroad Station is in Medford about two and a quarter-mile away. Holtsville is 56 miles from New York City. The median home value in Holtsville is said to be around $384,800, making it one of the most affordable suburbs in Long Island.


6. Wantagh

Wantagh is in the County of Nassau in the town of Hempstead. The Wantagh School District has a GreatSchools rating of nine out of 10. It offers access to the Long Island Railroad Station and is 37 miles from New York City. Wantagh Park and Forest City Community Park are great for outdoor entertainment and recreational activities. An outdoor amphitheater is a place to go and see several live concerts and festivals. The median home value in Wantagh is said to be around $469,700.


7. Bellmore

Bellmore is situated in the town of Hempstead in Nassau County. The Bellmore School District has a GreatSchools rating of nine out of 10. Easy access to the Long Island Railroad Station is available in this suburb. The East Bay Park and the Newbridge Road Park are terrific for outdoor recreation and entertainment events. Bellmore is within 35 and a half miles from New York City. The median home value in Bellmore is said to be around $469,000.


8. Massapequa

Massapequa is a separate suburb from Massapequa Park. It is in the town of Oyster Bay in Nassau County. The Massapequa School District has a rating of eight out of 10. The Massapequa Preserves are available for outdoor recreational activities and entertainment. The Long Island Railroad Station is available for mass transit. Massapequa is 39 miles from New York City. The median home value of Massapequa is said to be around $497,000.


9. Manorville

Manorville is in the town of Riverhead in Suffolk County. The Eastport South Manor Central School District has a GreatSchools rating of seven out of 10. Manorville Hills County Park and Robert Cushman Murphy County Park are available for outdoor activities and entertainment. The nearest Long Island Railroad Station is in Mastic Shirley about six miles away. Manorville is 69 and a half miles from New York City. The median home value is said to be around $419,400.


10. Lake Ronkonkoma

Lake Ronkonkoma is in the town of Islip in Suffolk County. The Sachem Central School District is rated with an eight out of 10. Here you can enjoy Lake Ronkonkoma County Park for outdoor entertainment and recreational activities. The Long Island Railroad Station offers close access for mass transit. Lake Ronkonkoma is within 53 miles of New York City. The median home value is said to be around $351,900.


These are some of the most affordable suburbs in the Long Island Region. Each offering its unique charm and many with high school ratings.


Additionally, these listed suburbs offer good or great amenities as well as access to mass transit systems for commuters. Many are also relatively close to NYC making them terrific places to raise a family with kids or without.

2 views0 comments